nion's blog

fail2ban is used by many people to prevent certain types of DoS attacks. I use it myself to reduce trackback spam a little bit.

While this tool becomes quite handy in such situations it is also not generally recommend because you can shoot yourself in the foot. If one of the used filters has a bug and results in incorrect parsing your fail2ban installation might end up banning arbitrary IP addresses or even your own IP range (not even mentioning IP spoofing).
There existed at least two bugs of this kind to my knowledge and since regex might not always be easy I'm sure there will be more in the future.

Since I didn't want to look for a specific regex bug in one of the filters I thought about IP spoofing again and looked at fail2bans filters. What I needed was a filter processing log entries of a service listening on a UDP socket as TCP/IP spoofing over the internet doesn't really work well these days. Finding such a filter would mean an instant win situation. To my surprise there is such a filter: config/filter.d/named.conf

This filter is used to parse log entries consisting of denied DNS queries produced by bind. Interestingly there is even an article at debian-administration describing how to setup fail2ban to mitigate a DNS DDoS attack. This is of course a bad idea and I have no idea why this filter is shipped in a default fail2ban installation. DoSing abritary IP addresses with this filter in use becomes as easy as firing up scapy and querying the server with a forged source IP:

>>> send(IP(dst="81.169.172.197",src="xx.46.63.71")/UDP()/DNS(rd=1,qd=DNSQR(qname="foao.modprobe.de")))
.
Sent 1 packets.

This ends up as:
May 26 22:32:22 modprobe named[30245]: client xx.46.63.71#53: query 'foao.modprobe.de/A/IN' denied

in the bind logs which in turn results in:
2010-05-26 22:32:05,551 fail2ban.actions: WARNING [named-refused] Ban xx.46.63.71

In this example the spoofed IP was xx.46.63.71 which is not under my control.

Mission statement: don't use fail2ban unless you really want to shoot yourself in the foot or know pretty well what you're doing